Tradeify vs Lucid Trading: which is easier to pass and pay out?
Tradeify and Lucid Trading compared on their own published rules: profit targets, loss limits, consistency rules and payouts, plus how each account did in our benchmark, where the same made-up trader is replayed against every account. On our 6 measures, Tradeify comes out ahead on 1 and Lucid Trading on 0, with 5 level.
The verdict, category by category
| Tradeify | Lucid Trading | Edge | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Easiest challenge to pass pass chance in our benchmark | Select 50K (Flex): 44% | LucidFlex 50K: 43% | Level |
| Best chance of passing and getting paid passed and reached a first payout, in our benchmark | Select 50K (Flex): 41% | LucidFlex 50K: 34% | Tradeify |
| Most room before failing largest maximum loss; static beats trailing | 4% trailing, locks at start (Select 50K (Flex)) | 4% trailing, locks at start (LucidFlex 50K) | Level |
| Highest profit split | 90% | 90% | Level |
| Quickest first payout | 5 days | 5 days | Level |
| Accounts with no consistency rule | 0 of 1 | 0 of 1 | Level |
Which should you choose?
- Choose Tradeify if you want the best chance of passing and then reaching a first payout.
- Still not sure? The right firm depends on your strategy, not ours. Upload your backtest and see your own pass and payout chance at both.
Test your strategy at Tradeify Test at Lucid Trading
Evaluations: Tradeify Select 50K (Flex) vs Lucid Trading LucidFlex 50K
| Tradeify | Lucid Trading | |
|---|---|---|
| Account | Select 50K (Flex) | LucidFlex 50K |
| Profit target | 6% | 6% |
| Daily loss limit | None | None |
| Maximum loss | 4% trailing, locks at start | 4% trailing, locks at start |
| Minimum days | 3 | None |
| Time limit | None | None |
| Consistency rule | 40% challenge | 40% challenge |
| First payout | After 5 days, 0.1%+ profit | After 5 days, 1.5%+ profit |
| Profit split | 90% | 90% |
| Price | $165 for $50K | $115 for $50K |
| Pass chance (benchmark) | 44% | 43% |
| First payout chance (benchmark) | 41% | 34% |
| Best risk per trade | 0.3% | 0.3% |
| Fee spent per first payout, per $100 | $244 | $294 |
| Rules checked | 25 Oct 2026 | 8 Nov 2026 |
Where a firm has more than one account of a type, the one that did best in our benchmark is shown. "Fee spent per first payout" is what every $100 of challenge fee works out at once failed attempts are counted.
Every account at both firms
| Firm | Account | Type | Profit target | Daily loss | Max loss | Consistency | First payout | Split |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| T | Select 50K (Flex) | 1-step | 6% | None | 4% trailing, locks at start | 40% challenge | After 5 days, 0.1%+ profit | 90% |
| LT | LucidFlex 50K | 1-step | 6% | None | 4% trailing, locks at start | 40% challenge | After 5 days, 1.5%+ profit | 90% |
About the two firms
Tradeify
Tradeify's Select 50K (Flex) is a futures evaluation with a $3,000 (6%) target, a $2,000 (4%) drawdown that trails your end-of-day balance and locks at your start plus $100, 3 minimum days, and a 40% consistency rule that applies only during the evaluation.
Futures
Rules to watch: Futures. EOD trailing drawdown locks at start + $100. 40% consistency applies only during the evaluation. Select Flex pays every 5 winning days, up to 50% of profits and capped at $2,500 on 50K. Source: help.tradeify.co/en/articles/12853921-select-evaluation-accounts
Lucid Trading
Lucid Trading is a futures firm. LucidFlex 50K needs $3,000 (6%) with a $2,000 (4%) drawdown, an optional daily loss limit, and a 40% consistency rule in the evaluation that doesn't apply once funded. Lucid didn't state the drawdown type when we checked, so we model it as end-of-day trailing that locks at the start.
Futures
Rules to watch: Futures. Optional daily loss limit. Payouts need 5 days of $150+ profit, are up to 50% of profit ($2,000 max on 50K) and limited to 5 before the account goes live. The drawdown type wasn't stated, so it's modelled as EOD trailing that locks at the start. Sources: support.lucidtrading.com/en/articles/12945790-lucidflex-evaluation-account and support.lucidtrading.com/en/articles/12945796-lucidflex-payouts
Questions
Is Tradeify or Lucid Trading easier to pass?
They are about the same. In our benchmark Tradeify's Select 50K (Flex) passed 44% of the time and Lucid Trading's LucidFlex 50K 43%.
Which is more likely to pay out, Tradeify or Lucid Trading?
Of their challenges, Tradeify's Select 50K (Flex) (41%) gave the better chance of passing and reaching a first payout in our benchmark, against 34% for Lucid Trading's LucidFlex 50K. This ranks the rules, not the firms' payout records.
Which has the better profit split, Tradeify or Lucid Trading?
They are the same at best: 90%.
Which gives more room on drawdown, Tradeify or Lucid Trading?
Tradeify's most forgiving account allows 4% trailing, locks at start (Select 50K (Flex)); Lucid Trading's allows 4% trailing, locks at start (LucidFlex 50K). A static limit never moves up behind you, so it is worth more than a trailing one of the same size.
Do Tradeify and Lucid Trading have consistency rules?
Tradeify: 1 of 1 accounts do. Lucid Trading: 1 of 1 accounts do.
More comparisons
- Apex Trader Funding vs Tradeify
- Topstep vs Tradeify
- Apex Trader Funding vs Lucid Trading
- Take Profit Trader vs Tradeify
- MyFundedFutures vs Tradeify
- FTMO vs The5%ers
- FTMO vs FundedNext
- FTMO vs FundingPips
- FundedNext vs FundingPips
- FTMO vs E8 Markets
- FTMO vs Alpha Capital Group
- The5%ers vs FundedNext
PropPassCheck isn't paid by either firm and has no affiliate links. The benchmark ranks rules, not your trading. Confirm the rules on each firm's site before you buy.